Over the past two years, we have tried a couple different budgeting and money saving systems such as extreme couponing (who has the time for this?!) and using a spreadsheet to manage our checking account. Both of which, just didn't prevented us from overspending. It was astounding how easy it was to overspend, even when we thought we had a budget under control. Debt was growing...
Upon talking with several friends who have taken the Dave Ramsey "Financial Peace University" through their churches, I became curious. I began to research his teachings and found that he is all about dividing your income into categories, then carrying cash in envelopes pertaining to each category, among many other great ideas which I will share in a bit. But as I researched his program, both Trevor and myself just couldn't grasp the cash and carry method because:
- Who carries cash anymore?
- We do online shopping, so if all of our money is in cash, what do we do?
- We both grocery shop and run errands, so how do we coordinate who carries the envelopes at which time?
- What happens if we lose an envelope filled with cash?
- We have USAA for our banking and we do all of our banking online.
- Snowballing your debt payments. (http://www.daveramsey.com/article/get-out-of-debt-with-the-debt-snowball-plan/)
- Having an emergency fund of at least $1000 for life's unexpected (http://www.daveramsey.com/company/faq/#emergency_fund)
- Create categories in which you spend your money (http://christianpf.com/how-to-use-dave-ramseys-envelope-system-to-budget/)
- Only spend what you have!
For the remainder of this post, I'm only going to discuss the debit cards and categories we use- the debt and emergency fund can be looked up online.
Since we have free unlimited checking accounts, we decided to try the "envelope" system via debit cards. Believe it or not, we have 15 checking accounts and 1 savings account. Don't worry, we actually only carry cards for 9 of them since they are the categories in which we mostly spend. The other categories are checking "savings" accounts that we transfer money into, but aren't frequently used. Here are the categories we created:
- Paycheck Account (This is where our paychecks get deposited)
- Gas
- Groceries
- Home (Target/Walmart/Household)
- Date Night
- Kristen's Allowance
- Trevor's Allowance
- Gifts (Birthdays, Christmas, Anniversary)
- Pet (vet, food, treats, toys)
- Vacation (Only used when we're on vacation)
- Emergency Fund (EMERGENCIES ONLY!)
- Bills
- Rent
- Tithe
- Auto Registration (it happens every year, so why not save a little each month?)
- Future Home (Savings account)
The red categories are the accounts that we carry a labeled debit card for; the black accounts are categories that we either don't spend out of or we do primarily online banking with them.
Our system:
- Our paychecks are deposited into one checking account labeled "Paycheck Account." This is where our budget stems from.
- Since Trevor's income varies with each paycheck, we budget with what minimum amount his paychecks always are. Any monies left over in that pay period go toward debt or into the house savings account.
- I use the sample spreadsheet below to transfer funds into the corresponding accounts each payday. As the funds are transferred from the Paycheck Account into the corresponding category account, I highlight the cell on the spreadsheet to know that it has been accounted for.
- Once all funds are transferred out of the Paycheck Account into the categories, we then use our debit cards for purchases and/or online banking to pay bills and other items.
Since doing this process, we have found that BIG areas of overspending for us were in grocery shopping and date nights. By going on a date one to two times a week or buying unnecessary items at the grocery store added up fast!
Here are the benefits we have already seen from this system:
- This process has been a fairly smooth transition and we have found areas in which we need to increase our budget and decrease our budget.
- Our money is transparent to both of us. We both know what goes where and how to spend it.
- We haven't gone without. We still have our own "fun money" for our WANTS and have confidence that we will have enough money for our NEEDS too.
- We aren't using credit cards
- Our debt is decreasing
- We are still SAVING money too!
I'm not saying that our system is 100% effective or what's best for you and your situation, however, it has helped Trevor and I manage our money, which in turn, has alleviated lot of stress between us. So far, we love it and I hope you will too!
I'd be more than happy to share my spreadsheet template with you! Just leave a comment with your email address and I'll send it over.
Hello! I came across your blog from pinterest. I really like your idea of using debit cards to budget. If the offer is still there, I would like the template you use! Email: aandii@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteAlso, you and your husband each have a debit card for each account, correct?
Thanks!
HI, i also came across your blog on pinterest i was wondering if you could send me your spreadsheet? please =) anavic1421@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteHello! I would love a copy of your spreadsheet! My husband and I did the cash envelope system and it was amazing! We had a lot of the difficulties with it that you mentioned, and I think this would be an amazing way to do it! Thanks for sharing. swilson27@gmail.com.
ReplyDeleteThank you!!
Looks like everyone if finding you on Pinterest, that's also where I found this post! LOVE LOVE LOVE the idea of using the debit cards!!! My husband and I just got married in August and creating a budget has been on the list of things to do! Would love to use your spreadsheet to help with the process. It looks super strait to the point which is what we need. Thanks so much susanpants@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteHello! I love this idea please email me your spreadsheet! tamaraguystarks@gmail.com Thank you!
ReplyDeletehello
ReplyDeleteI love this idea. please email me your spreadsheet to flor.lehocky@gmail.com
Hello, I too found your great post on Pinterest and would love to get a copy of the spreadsheet. asyambrown@gmail.com . Thanks!
ReplyDeletecan you please send me the template? Thanks so much. daniellalmanzar@yahoo.com
ReplyDeleteCan you send me the template please. rissa.murray@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteI'd really appreciate the template as well! We tried the cash system, but we also have USAA and found it very difficult. How do you go about opening the other accounts? Can it be done online or all on the phone?
ReplyDeletekeona.hunter@yahoo.com
THanks!!
Hello, I'd like to use your template as well! amiyagi89@gmail.com.
ReplyDeleteThanks!
How did you get 15 separate accounts at one bank? Could you please send me your template? jricedavis@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteThanks,
Jennifer
Can you please send me your template? sherylkatc@yahoo.com
ReplyDeleteThank you!!
Makes more sense to me since I do all of my banking and bill paying online as well, thanks! jerrinmendoza@yahoo.com
ReplyDeleteI would love to use your template as well. cyecei@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteI would love to get a copy of your template. My husband just started a new job and we think this would be a great way to figure out how to manage our finances. Thank you! My email is am.eagle.girl07@hotmail.com
ReplyDeleteI think this is brilliant! I would so grateful if I could use your template as well. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteemail: kelver29@yahoo.com
Please send me the template as well!!
ReplyDeletelyssrjac91@yahoo.com
Love the idea, please send template to me as well pattersonmichelle@rocketmail.com
ReplyDeleteLove the idea, can you send me your template? Thanks. nita1254@hotmail.com
ReplyDeleteLove the idea! Can you please send me the template you used? Thanks! :) Emily@etristate.com
ReplyDeleteI found you on Pinterest. Could you please send me the template? Thank you!
ReplyDeleteRachel.harbuck@gmail.com
I found you on Pinterest as well. Could I get a copy? Thank you so much! tiffers5150@gmail.com
ReplyDeletelove this! would love of a copy if the offer still stands n.martin@gatech.edu thanks!
ReplyDeleteThis is genius! I will be starting this week! Please email me your the,plate shawfamily2007@yahoo.com thank you so much
ReplyDeleteWould like a copy of the template please! Love this idea!
ReplyDeletelittlebear72ac@gmail.com
Thank you! God Bless!
Hi! I would love to have your spreadsheet! my email is bri@clubtan.com
ReplyDeleteThank you!!!
Hi, I would love to try out your spreadsheet, can you email me a copy please? dieanuhh@yahoo.com thanks!
ReplyDeleteWallnerjax@bellsouth.net
ReplyDeletelove this, would you mind sending me a copy of your spreadsheet. koren.carpenter@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteI Would Like To Try This. Can You Send Me A Copy Of Your Spreadsheet. Treysmomnc@yahoo.Com
ReplyDeletethanks
I would love a copy of the spreadsheet. Thank you hsweeten07@yahoo.com
ReplyDeleteI would love a copy of your spreadsheet! sonyawilliams02@yahoo.com
ReplyDeleteI would love to use your spreadsheet! megmarie5@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteThanks!
I found you on Pinterest, and I LOVE this! If you are still sharing your spreadsheet, I would love to have it, too! Email is englecourtney@gmail.com. Thanks so, so much!!
ReplyDeletePlease share your spreadsheet, I need help! julie@theprecisionline.com
ReplyDeleteThank you!
I'd love the spreadsheet if you dont mind sharing. miamieventplanner@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteDying for this
ReplyDeleteSpread sheet like everyone else!
Please! Michelledm.martin@gmail.com
I would love a copy of this spreadsheet too! Kakristoff@hotmail.com
ReplyDeleteI would like a copy as well. Well done. PNC will also offer multiple checking accounts, but your direct deposit has to be over a certain amount each month. anohewitt3@yahoo.com
ReplyDeleteCan you please send me a copy of your template. Thanks. . kieabarnes@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteI love the dave ramsey method but had yet to figure out a solution to not doing cash in envelopes due to the same fact you mentioned, which is we bank with USAA and its all online. I would love to have you send me the spreadsheet if its still available at taracrispin@yahoo.com
ReplyDeletethanks so much for your inventive way of solving the cash situation. I hope this will work for us
Please send me your spreadsheet! haleymcarson@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteHi thanks so much for your info!!! can you pleas send me a copy of your spreedsheet! thanks so much blinky991@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteHello, can I please have a copy of your template. Thank you so much.
ReplyDeletejjastronomo@gmail.com
came across your blog and was wondering about getting a copy of your template. <3 thanks in advance! sparrow8638@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteHi, can I please get a copy of your template. Thank-you!
ReplyDeletemariposamiriam@yahoo.com
Can you please send me a copy of your template? Thanks! kristinmichelle12@yahoo.com
ReplyDeleteGreat idea. Can I also get a copy of the template.?? andradeguy@hotmail.com
ReplyDeleteThis looks amazing! We bank with USAA as well. How did you get all the accounts opened and going?
ReplyDeleteHello.. This is wonderful! I have gone through Financial Peace University myself. I also bank with USAA. I would love your spreadsheet and info on how you opened all those accounts. Threelittleloves@gmail.com Thanks so much for sharing!
ReplyDeleteI'd like the template as well please. I like this system. Tanishanwalker@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteI love this new idea :) I would like a template of the spreadsheet so I can get ready to help pay for my college tuition
ReplyDeletegryffondorsevenyear2014@gmail.com
Great idea! I would love to try it. I am more likely to spend cash if I have it on me. I can be more disciplined using a debit card, believe it or not. Would love the template! Carrie.e.ford@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteI'd love the template! Thanks! Keri.keglar@hotmail.com
ReplyDeleteThis is a crazy question, but what did you use to write the categories on the cards?
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for this post! I want to use an envelope system but had the same issue you did above. The separate checking accounts never occurred to me. I am going to call my bank and see if we can do this. I'd also love to try your spreadsheet if you don't mind sending it over.
ReplyDeletesarahbeesley@me.com
great idea! If you don't mind. Can you send me the template as well? kristinapopik@mac.com
ReplyDeleteLove the idea of using the debit cards instead of the cash/envelopes. Can you please send me your template to pash4@embarqmail.com
ReplyDeleteThanks
Would love to get a copy of the spreadsheet also! Great idea about doing cash system through debit cards!! love it! alofa.aveina@gmail.com Thanks in advance!
ReplyDeleteHi, I would love to try out your spreadsheet, can you email me a copy please?
ReplyDeletelesly.guerrero@gmail.com
interested in the spreadsheet, please! :)
ReplyDeletelj.bennett88@gmail.com
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThanks send spreadsheet
ReplyDeletePhoebusbill@yahoo.com
We have tried the debit card for our own spending, but not our entire budget... this makes sense. Great tips. could you please send a copy of the spreadsheet - ecsnyder75@gmail.com
ReplyDeleteIs there a way that this spreadsheet can be emailed (msmuscular@gmail.com) or placed on a Google Drive?
ReplyDeletecan i please get your template?
ReplyDeleteIf this is still an option, I'd love to use your template. How were you able to get so many checking accounts? I think this us a great idea especially in paying for everything online.
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing!
Mitzi
Zachandmitzihorn@yahoo.com
I would love to get a copy of your template! Thanks
ReplyDeleteMoorefam2000@gmail.com
Hello i would love a copy of your spreadsheet as well, such a great idea.
ReplyDeletelovetosk8@gmail.com
Thanks,
Sam
I came across your post on Pinterest and am interested in getting a copy of your spreadsheet. I love the check card idea instead of carrying cash. alarasteph@yahoo.com
ReplyDeleteThanks, Aimee